EDITORIAL: HEAVY HANDED FIST OF ST. MARY’S SHERIFF HALL ON BLOCKING PUBLIC COMMENTS

HEAVY HANDED FIST OF ST. MARY’S SHERIFF HALL
ON BLOCKING PUBLIC COMMENTS

EDITORIAL
BY JOHN E. O’CONNOR

In an age where transparency and accountability are paramount, the St. Mary’s County Sheriff’s Department has found itself in the eye of a digital storm due to its violation of the public’s constitutional rights.

According to a response to an information request from THE CHESAPEAKE TODAY, at least 3,347 emails indicate instances where the department has deleted thousands of comments from its Facebook page. These deletions predominantly targeted comments critical of the current administration led by Sheriff Steve Hall, Assistant Sheriff Clay Safford, and Captain Shawn Moses, particularly regarding their perceived lack of transparency.

Notably, records indicate that during the tenure of the previous sheriff, Tim Cameron, the social media page rarely, if ever, required the deletion of Facebook comments. This stark contrast has raised significant concerns about censorship and the unconstitutional suppression of public discourse.

Social media platforms like Facebook have become modern public forums where citizens engage with local government and law enforcement. St. Mary’s County Sheriff’s Department’s official Facebook page was a hub for sharing updates, addressing community concerns, and responding to public queries. But as engagement grew, so did controversy. Over time, residents noticed their comments disappearing—sometimes without explanation. Was it an issue of inappropriate content moderation or something more concerning?

THE CHESAPEAKE TODAY filed a Public Information Act request to investigate the Sheriff’s Department’s social media moderation practices.

The response to the Maryland Public Information Act request confirmed suspicions that, in actuality, there are over 21,000 emails related to their Facebook page and the possible deletion of comments. However, the scope was narrowed because the sheer volume of deletions was so vast, narrowing it down to 3,347 emails directly related to deleting comments from the Facebook page that were critical of the current administration.

While it’s understandable that some deletions were to enforce community guidelines, the sheer volume makes it impossible to say that every single one was purely due to someone violating a community guideline.

The practices of the Sheriff Steve Hall administration appear to be intentionally silencing dissenting voices to shield the department from legitimate criticism and accountability in a public forum. By doing so, the administration is violating the First Amendment rights of every person who has used the Facebook page and had their freedom of speech suppressed by this totalitarian approach to content moderation.

The St. Mary’s Sheriff’s Department should be acutely aware of the constitutional implications of such actions, especially in light of the landmark 2017 case against former Maryland Governor Larry Hogan. In that instance, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed a federal lawsuit alleging Governor Hogan violated constituents’ First Amendment rights by blocking users and deleting comments on his official Facebook page. The lawsuit contended that such practices unlawfully silenced dissenting voices in a public forum. The case was settled in 2018, with Governor Hogan agreeing to implement a more open social media policy that prohibits discrimination based on viewpoint and allows for broader constituent engagement.

This precedent establishes that government officials cannot censor speech on official social media platforms simply because it is critical or dissenting. By ignoring this legal precedent, the St. Mary’s County Sheriff’s Department risks eroding public trust and facing potential legal repercussions for infringing upon constitutionally protected free speech rights.

For an elected Sheriff, appointed Second-in-Command Clay Safford, and Administrative Captain Shawn Moses—leaders who have sworn an oath to uphold the law and protect the constitutional rights of the citizens they serve—their actions tell a different story. Instead of safeguarding the principles of transparency and free speech, their efforts appear more focused on shielding Steve Hall’s administration from criticism. In doing so, they undermine the rights they are sworn to protect, leaving the voices of the citizens of St. Mary’s County stifled under the weight of a leadership more concerned with self-preservation than public accountability.

This heinous violation of the constitutional rights of the citizens of St. Mary’s County notably comes twenty years after the Federal Courts found the St. Mary’s County Sheriff and his deputies violated the First Amendment rights of the public. The decision in Rossignol v Voorhaar 2003 Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that it is the right of the public to choose what to read, and the publisher of ST. MARY’S TODAY to criticize the Sheriff’s Department without a midnight raid of newsstands to remove all available copies of the Election Day 1998 edition of the newspaper before voters could read it before voting.

 

  • buzzsmarina.com
  • LINDAS NEW LOCATION OPENS SUNDAY FEB 4th
  • SPECIAL INVESTIGATIONS TIPS tctdinvestigations@yahoo.com
  • See website for special offers
  • Bull Shark from Potomac in 2010 Buzzs Marina
  • Bullshark Buzz's Marina
  • Mike Henderson at Buzzs Marina
  • Buzz's Marina fish tales
  • A Good Day at Buzz's Marina
  • Jacob and Nate from Buzz's Marina with their catch
  • Red fish from Buzz's Marina
  • Howard Bernstein with a nice croaker via Buzz's Marina
  • Family fishing at Buzz's Marina
  • Buzz's Marina records another great catch.
  • Buzz's Marina featured the huge cobia of Kyle Johnson on July 15, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina notes the July 10, 2017 catch of Tim and Mike Rice.
  • Buzz's Marina says that Ken, Jen, Pete and Jen got these beautiful blues out on the Dream Maker with Capt. Mike on July 16, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina with a plank full of fish caught by Sean Stack.
  • Buzz's Marina displays the great catch of the day of Travis
  • Buzz's Marina displays the proud catch of Teagan and Randy on July 10, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina featured Susan and Dave's catch on July 10, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina reports R. J. Henderson playing with the Cobias on the Stephen's Brothers boat on July 9, 2017.
  • Buzz's Marina featured the Charlie Steward Crab Boil on July 8, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina says Dave got this pretty Cobia fishing with Guy Stephens on July 7, 2017
  • Buzz's Marina noted that Laurie and Danny were taking advantage of the beach on the Fourth of July.
  • Buzz's Marina says Ida Mae's crew under Capt. Charlie Stewart got a three man limit of blues in 52 minutes on July 4, 2017.
  • Buzz's Marina reports Matt Robinson found plenty of whiting in the Mud Leeds on July 4, 2017.
  • Buzz's Marina heavy blues on July 19, 2017
  • After slaying the cobia they switched gears and jigged up these tackle busters! The seven pounder they got on a spinning rod. Capt Mike, Kenny and Tommy. Sept. 25, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Jonathan and Matthew jigging off of David's boat. Pretty obvious where they were. Buzz's Marina Sept. 2019
  • Michael got this Snakehead from the dock. Buzz's Marina
  • Doctor's Orders Charter today. Aug. 31, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Nice haul Doctor's Orders! Aug. 30, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Aug. 30, 2019 A great day on the Bay. Buzz's Marina
  • Aug. 30, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Johnny fished with Kyle Johnson. That's at least a 26 inch mackerel. Aug. 30, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • LP got a nice snakehead on a beetle spin. Good eats! Aug. 26, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Jim, Keith and Jeff got theirs! Aug. 24, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • Nick and Timmy really found some beauties! Aug. 23, 2019 Buzz's Marina
  • buzzsmarina.com
  • Jay Fleming got a beautiful cobia today. Good to see you back to your old haunt Jay! Buzz's Marina 2019
  • Rough as heck but the fishing was great! Sept. 10, 2019 Buzz's Marina, Ridge Md.
  • Timmy's catch from yesterday. Nice! Buzz's Marina Sept. 26, 2019
  •  govt Zoo of Incompetence
  • St. Mary's Commissioners compete with small businesses
  • Taxes, Taxes, Taxes. Graphic created by John E. O'Connor with AI.
  • Randy Guy the pickpocket of taxpayers
  • Tribute to the Mayor of Leonardtown Dan Burris created with the assistance of AI by John E. O'Connor
  • Josh Guy has first school board meeting with lots of kisses from teachers union
  • Convict Sheriff Steve Hall stomps on 1st Amendment.
  • Alisa Casas the Badge Bunny
  • DRONE FLEET created with AI by John E. O'Connor
  • Greedy Tax Hiking St. Mary's Commissioners
  • Sock it to Her
  • Two Sheriffs, No Guns
  • Two more years of insider trading for Pelosi
  • Hoyer will have to be carried out of Congress feet first
  • Raise electric rates, raise taxes
  • SIGN WARS 
  • HEWITT THE ANTI-CHRIST
  • BOLD LEADERS
  • My Daddy is Sheriff Steve Hall
  • HOT UNDER THE COLLAR
  • TO TELL THE TRUTH
  • Butter Up The Judge
  • JUSTICE FOR SALE
  • DUELING BANJOS
  • BIG BUCKS FOR BIG CHEESE CROSBY
  • SIGN WARS
  • KEFUFFLE OF CRIME
  • AMTRAK JOE WILL BE ON FIRST TRAIN 
  • Get to Know Your Judge Hopeful
  • Rino Larry
  • Too Far to the Left
  • 5 Stars or Else
  • Fortune Telling for Smart Lawyers
  • RIP Uncle Fred the Worm
  • ALIMONY SWEEPSTAKES LOSER
  • The Real Winner
  • Time for Chopticon Teacher to shop for new dress
  • St. Mary's Sheriff Palace and Taj Ma Hall
  • THE WORM VOTES TOO
  • Angela Alsobiden's Baggage
  • Gov. Wes Moore with Moore Bull about Clean Air
  • It's time to clean out the Hen House
  • That's Socialism
  • MAN OF THE YEAR IS MISS MARYLAND
  • The Hamas wing won't allow a Jew
  • Million Dollar Hot Dog Stand
  • What happened to all the deputies?
  • Million Dollar Hot Dog Stand
  • Polock Scotties
  • THE INVISIBLE CANDIDATE AND THE OLD HEN
  • Higher taxes for thee but not for me
  • Caught red-handed with his hand in liberal's pockets
  • GOP Board Blew Budget on Sheriff Palace
  • Where have all the deputies gone?
  • Who is the best Democrat, O'Malley or Hogan?
  • St. Mary's Board funds Sheriff Palace instead of Schools
  • Tom Jarboe's Destiny
  • LAWFARE  - One Trick Donkey

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Exit mobile version